Social Media Tune Up: Twitter Part 2

New York Marathon 2005, by Martineric via Flickr
Hot rod at Wintersun Festival, Coolangatta 2009Yesterday, as part of this Social Media Tune Up series, I wrote about Twitter and shared some general thoughts about how Twitter fits into my business strategy.

In this second post on the topic I focus on my approach to the whole business of following and being followed on Twitter. I emphasize that it’s my approach. There are a lot of different opinions about how best to use Twitter, with a variety of approaches.

The Twitter Following Game

By way of background, I’ve been on Twitter since February 2007.

Out of the more than 160 million Twitter users, I have 5,172 followers. I follow 4,040.

I don’t follow everyone back who follows me: and by the same token not everyone I follow returns the favor.

  • Of the 5,172 who follow me, I follow about 4,031, so about three quarters.
  • Of  the 4,040 I follow, most – some 4,106 – follow me back.

I have not aimed so far at following a huge number of people and in fact I am reasonably selective about who I follow.

The people – and some brands – I follow are in four broad categories:

  1. people – and some brands – I know or know about or find and have a strategic business interest in following
  2. colleagues and friends
  3. people whose blogs or tweets I read and find interesting
  4. people – and some brands – who follow me and seem to meet my criteria for following

Of the four categories of people to follow, as listed above, my activity for categories 2-4 is fairly serendipitous.

The one I find I need to work on strategically is Number 1: people – and some brands – I know, or know about, or find and have a strategic business interest in following.

Are there some models?

I have not so far observed a consistent pattern of followers/following numbers among various thought leaders on Twitter.

Twitterville by Shel IsraelShel Israel – @ShelIsrael – author of the excellent TwittervilleHow Businesses Can Thrive in the New Global Neighborhoods– has 21,575 followers and follows 1,790. Deborah Micek @coachdeb, co-author of Twitter RevolutionHow Social Media and Mobile Marketing is Changing the Way We Do Business and Market Online (the book that alerted so many to the opportunities – and the challenges – offered by Twitter) – has 22,106 followers and is following 10,080. Deb’s co-author, Warren Whitlock @WarrenWhitlock has 67,057 followers and he follows 64,155.

Among other social media thought leaders, Chris Pirillo @ChrisPirillo has 87,704 followers and follows only 1,014. David Meerman Scott @dmscott has 44,743 followers and follows 33,461.

There are some curiosities in all this follower/following field. Tony Hsieh @Zappos with 1,745,429 followers follows me – and 383,480 others: I have seen and listened to Tony live at an event and am a big fan but have never been introduced, whereas a friend who is another thought leader and mover and shaker in social media, someone I have chatted with at a barbecue and exchanged emails with does not include me in the 384 he follows (he has over 5,000 followers).

I don’t believe there is a “right” answer to questions of numbers of people to seek to have follow you or for you to follow.

I believe we each have to figure out what is right for us and our business objectives.

How I identify people to follow

Twitter RevolutionAs I mentioned above, some of my choices about which people or brands to follow seem to fall in place fairly serendipitously.

The one I focus on is, as mentioned, the category of people/brands I have a strategic business interest in following.

Some examples of groups of such Twitter users:

Coaches – I follow the advice of one of my mentors, the late Thomas Leonard, whom I heard say that if you want to be a coach, one of the things you should do is to hang out with coaches

Social media thought leaders – there is always something to learn about social media so lately I have been taking concerted action to follow some of the leaders in this field

PR and advertising people in Australia and New Zealand – part of my business is representing in Australia and NZ the social media release platform provider PitchEngine, so it makes sense to learn more about people in the PR and advertising industries in these countries and on Twitter

In fields like those, it is not difficult to find people on Twitter. I’m finding that most of the people in those groups who have blogs and/or LinkedIn profiles have their Twitter link displayed.

At times I will focus on finding Twitter users in a particular group with which I want to improve my connectedness. For example, the other day I took some serious time out to check out all the blogs – and their authors – listed in a blog post on one person’s list of 50 top social media blogs. With each of them, where I could find a Twitter account and was not already following them, I followed them. I also linked their blogs to my RSS reader.

Several followed me back fairly promptly, or we were already following one another. Some have followed me back after a few days. With one of those people I have now had an extended Skype chat and talked about some possible business collaboration. (A note: when you have this sort of experience, accept the fact that your friends who think Twitter is just about sharing information about breakfast menus will quite probably not get it!)

It takes time, rather than effort, to build a good list of people to follow

My basic reason for sharing the example of connecting with social media thought leaders is that there are ways to sift and filter the vast tribe of Twitter users and identify the tribes you want to connect with and the people in those tribes you want to follow and those you would like to follow you.

And with that particular group I also added each to a list I have on Twitter – one of the benefits of which is that is I can now watch a whole stream of discussion by the smarter people in this field, without the distraction of other topics and voices in the more general Twitter stream or even the broad stream of those I’m following beyond that particular list.

I’ll go into the topic of Twitter lists in a subsequent post in this series.

Coming soon

I’ll be posting further in this series on Twitter early next week, and will share how I approach the issue of how to handle being followed on Twitter by people I don’t know.

My approach, which is quite personal and hands-on, and does not use the automation processes used by many people, could well be regarded by some as quaint, old-fashioned and seriously inefficient.  I know because I’ve been told so! That’s ok – I recognize that different people and different businesses have different needs.

But at the very least I believe that anyone getting into Twitter for business would do well to resist the pressure to get an army of followers and instead spend some time getting to know how things work, following a few at a time at first and spending some time listening to the conversation before jumping in too eagerly.

If you would like to share how you approach Twitter and perhaps how you view the whole “following/follower” exercise, I hope you will give us the benefit of your experience and wisdom.

(Update: picking up on the good advice of David Meerman Scott – @dmscott – in the comments, my Twitter ID is @deswalsh)

(New Update: see also Part 1 and Part 3 of this series about Twitter.)

Image credit: Marathon de New York, by Martineric via Flickr – CC by-sa

Three Excellent Books on Social Media

A Triple Book Notice Because I Haven’t Yet Reviewed These Books and I Feel Remiss About That

It was actually a resolution of mine well before New Year’s Day, to review all the books that have been piling up alongside my desk, mostly books on or relating to social media.

But New Year’s Day came and went.

So this is a notice as a precursor to the review I still plan to do of each of three of those books.

And while I have read only one right through, I have read enough of the others to be able to recommend all three wholeheartedly.

Without further ado, they are:

Paul Chaney’s the digital handshake – seven proven strategies to grow your business using social media

Gary Vaynerchuk’s Crushit! Why Now is the Time to Cash in on Your Passion

Shel Israel’s Twitterville – How Businesses Can Thrive in the new Global Neighborhoods

Paul Chaney, whose book provides an incomparable overview of the social media phenomenon, is  highly respected by his peers and is an all-round nice guy to boot. He is one of my most valued friends – interestingly most of our communication has been virtual, partly because there is this rather large ocean, the Pacific, between our two countries. From explaining the new communications paradigm and why that should matter to anyone in business, Paul guides the reader through a complete strategic framework to employ social media to build any business.

Gary Vaynerchuk is a force of nature, a man of great passion for what he does and a truly impressive record in business, by any standard. I had the privilege of hearing him speak at the BlogWorld & New Media Expo in Las Vegas in 2008. He is the real deal and his book is a great read about branding and about social media. It is also a sometimes confronting challenge for all of us to look seriously at what our true passion is and then to align our business and our life with that.

Shel Israel is a standout observer and commentator on social media, not just because he has long experience as a practitioner in and writer on communications, but because he takes a global view. He also has a wonderfully lucid, highly communicative writing style. Over the past few years he has interviewed many people around the globe on blogging and other aspects of social media, so his take on social media is as highly informed by his knowledge of how things look in Beijing and in Adelaide, Australia, to mention just a couple of places, as it is of how they look in San Francisco or New York City. His examples of how Twitter is being used by various businesses large and small – and in some specific instances not used, foolhardily as he shows, by some other businesses – are priceless.

Three very different books by very different men. One thing these three man have in common is that they are generous with information and insights. I learn from each of them every time I read or hear what they have to say.

By the way, each its own right is a good book to give to friends or associates or family members who say: “I don’t get why you are so enthusiastic about/ interested in/ curious about (Twitter, Facebook, blogging, YouTube, LinkedIn, social media – check the one that applies)” and you then spend half an hour or so trying to explain, until you notice that their eyes are rolling back in their head.

On second thoughts, maybe not family members, if you don’t want to waste your money). But do get your own copies.

Picture credit – my pic.

Disclaimer: the links are to my Amazon Associates account, so if you click through and buy them there I will benefit (about one cup of coffee, tops, I think): but hopefully good bookstores will have them too. I bought my copies of Crushit! and Twitterville respectively: Paul Chaney kindly gifted me a copy of his book.

How Many Million Bloggers Did You Say? Shel in China

Along with no doubt many, many others, I am watching with fascination Shel Israel’s unfolding adventures in the Middle Kingdom.

Chinese Blogger Conference 2008 - CNBloggercon '08For those who just came in, Shel, who has an incomparable overview of social media internationally and its impact on business and culture, is currently visiting China for the first time. He is part of the China 2.0 tour and also keynoting at the Chinese Blogger Conference 2008 (Cnbloggercon ’08) this coming weekend, November 15-16.

Having visited Beijing myself for the first time in November last year, I’m taking particular interest, given that Shel is also doing the first impression exercise.

On what is obviously an activity-packed tour, he is doing his best to get some blog posts out and they make great reading.

As well as doing some regulation tourist activities such as climbing up to a section of the Great Wall, he is also gleaning information and insights into the China blogosphere and social media space and sharing those in his blog and on Twitter.

Kaiser Kuo & Shel Israel

I must admit I was quite dazzled last year by some of the numbers being thrown around, such as the number of Chinese bloggers and the number of people using bulletin boards. Being in business as a social media strategist, I naturally found myself trying to translate those numbers in terms of what they might mean for, say, social media consulting or other marketing opportunities.

I then started to listen more attentively and ask some questions. Which meant that I started to understand that such estimates could vary quite dramatically and should in any case be looked at carefully in terms of what the numbers might mean, for example how the gross number of bloggers might translate into estimating numbers of business bloggers.

From the post I read today, it looks as if Shel is having some not dissimilar experiences:

I learned that the 100-million bloggers estimate I was planning to use at my CNBloggercon talk would have drawn laughter. The real number is closer to 25 million. Bulletin Board Messages remain much more popular, with nearly 70 million people enjoying anonymity as they exchange information and opinion. Most blogs are very social. They are rarely political and almost never business related.

That bore out what I had learned last year and in subsequent observation from afar. Clearly the idea of a “business blog” has some way to go before it is as pervasive of the Chinese blogosphere as it is in, say, the USA.

Of course, the numbers in China are still huge – and there is amazing scope for growth and for new and expanding market opportunities.

I’m looking forward to more of Shel’s posts on his journeys in the Middle Kingdom. Our Marco Polo of social media.

As well as subscribing to Shel’s Global Neighbourhoods, you can keep up with his tour and impressions on a more “as it happens” basis” via Twitter.

Photo credits: Kaiser Kuo & Shel Israel – shelisrael1 via flickr – CC; Marco Polo Traveling – Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Lonnie Hodge to Speak at China Bloggercon 2008

China Bloggercon 2008I’d love to be able to attend China Bloggercon 2008 in Guangzhou, China, a couple of weeks from now – November 15th to 16th to be  precise.

Having been just over a month ago at another gathering of bloggers and other new media enthusiasts in Las Vegas, NV, USA – BlogWorld & New Media Expo 2008 - I know what a buzz it is to hang out for a few days with people who have a shared enthusiasm for blogging and podcasting.

The event in Guangzhou will be, if I’m not mistaken, the third China Bloggercon. I understand that it is expected to attract around 500 participants.

A couple of people I know are on the speaker list, including as keynote, as has been reported in a few places now, social media commentator Shel Israel, whose Global Neighbourhoods blog is a great source of information and insight on the takeup and application of social media around the world.

Lonnie B. HodgeAlso on the list is my friend and colleague, Professor Lonnie B. Hodge, who is a long-term Asia resident and now lives right in Guangzhou. Lonnie is CEO of CultureFish Media, of which I am an Associate.

Next week, Lonnie and I will be launching a new Internet radio program about China. We will be having a conversation each week about doing business, especially online, in China, about social media in China and probably ranging out from time to time to a wider regional perspective. We have started to line up some very interesting guests. Watch this space!

GM Blogger Bob Lutz Interviewed by Shel Israel

One of the first names that comes up when anyone talks about corporate blogging is that of General Motors VP Bob Lutz. His use of the GM FastLane blog is a standard reference for how a corporate executive might make effective use of blogging. Lutz gets not one but ten references in Debbie Weil’s The Corporate Blogging Book.

Shel Israel has interviewed Bob Lutz on the subject of social media within General Motors and more generally. Evidently this is the first time Lutz has agreed to an exclusive interview on the subject.

As a social media consultant for business, I found the interview riveting, have watched it again and intend to watch it a couple more times at least. Here is a 72 year old executive (seniors rule OK!) explaining how social media/blogging have helped his company both in terms of external communication with the media, customers and the general public and how it can help internal communications.

Seventeen minutes on how blogging and other social media can work in and for the enterprise. Evidence based, practical, insightful.

Some points I picked up on the first viewing:

  • Lutz was surprised to find that the primary readership of the blog turned out to be the media – “the number one readers of the FastLane blog”
  • he hopes journalists will now pause before writing a “really stupid piece” on GM, in the knowledge that GM has a way of responding and explaining that does not have to be mediated by the mainstream media and they will not want to be embarrassed by being shown up in front of their peers in the FastLane blog
  • he felt that GM were previously treated poorly by the media (always “glass half empty” stories) but he can no longer complain about how new products are treated in the press (“glass half full”)
  • a public-facing corporate blog helps the public to see a corporation less in the old way (a monolith) and more as it is, a collection of diverse individuals, all trying to do the right thing for the shareholders and for the American public
  • in corporate America, official communication had reached a point where it was no longer communication (pre-digested, sanitized, everything positive, no longer taken very seriously because it’s pre-packaged)
  • blogging by various executives where they communicate spontaneously puts a human face on the corporation
  • he thinks if blogging had been around in earlier days, Lee Iaccoca would have been a blogger!
  • internally, blogging is “an incredibly powerful tool for knitting a culture together”
  • in the future, social media will be the preferred means of communication
  • apart from condolences, he almost never writes a letter these days
  • he hopes Ford Motor Company do a lot of internal blogging these days (for their sake)

In my experience, corporate executives are more interested in what other corporate executives have to say about most things, including new technologies, than they are in what consultants and technology salespeople have to say. And rightly so.

Which makes this interview, from my corporate blogging/social media consultant’s viewpoint, pure gold.