Telstra Shuts Down Corporate Blogging Experiment

 nwat490

Telstra, Australia’s still-dominant telco, yesterday shut down its corporate blogging site nowwearetalking.com.au

CEO David Thodey’s letter announcing the shutdown promised “Telstra will launch a new corporate blogging website later this year”.

In keeping with the expressions of opinion from the opinionati when nowwearetalking launched back in 2005, from congratulatory/welcoming through curious/cautious to dismissive, blogosphere commentary on the shutdown, for example the comment stream on the mUmBRELLA post on the story, covers a spectrum of views from the “maybe it was a good thing” school to the unapologetically “good riddancers”. My impression is that there are significantly fewer voices saying it was or might have been a good thing than there are those of people glad, indeed very glad, to see the site gone.

Long time commentator on telecoms, the always well-informed and, in my observation over a number of years, always straight-talking Stuart Corner is in the good riddance camp.

Liam Tung at ZDNet provides a fairly non-judgemental synopsis of the nowwearetalking story and quotes mUmBRELLA’s Tim Burrows as being disappointed that the site is gone.

I believe it was a good thing that the experiment was tried. If nothing else, it showed up what can happen with a corporate blogging site when a corporation is battling not only its competitors but the nation’s government.

The general impression I have from zipping through the headlines on this topic in my online searching is that Tim Burrows was probably on the money when he opined yesterday to ZDNet that the site was just too much associated with former Telstra mouthpiece, the larger than life Phil Burgess and the Trujillo headed regime, and had to go.

No doubt the bones of this experiment in corporate blogging will be picked over, with lessons drawn and theories propounded, for some time to come. 

Media students, start your keyboards! I’m betting your lecturer will be setting nowwearetalking as an assignment before the week is out.

Image info: screenshot of nowwearetalking.com from Dec 2005, from The Wayback Machine at Archive.org

GM Blogger Bob Lutz Interviewed by Shel Israel

One of the first names that comes up when anyone talks about corporate blogging is that of General Motors VP Bob Lutz. His use of the GM FastLane blog is a standard reference for how a corporate executive might make effective use of blogging. Lutz gets not one but ten references in Debbie Weil’s The Corporate Blogging Book.

Shel Israel has interviewed Bob Lutz on the subject of social media within General Motors and more generally. Evidently this is the first time Lutz has agreed to an exclusive interview on the subject.

As a social media consultant for business, I found the interview riveting, have watched it again and intend to watch it a couple more times at least. Here is a 72 year old executive (seniors rule OK!) explaining how social media/blogging have helped his company both in terms of external communication with the media, customers and the general public and how it can help internal communications.

Seventeen minutes on how blogging and other social media can work in and for the enterprise. Evidence based, practical, insightful.

Some points I picked up on the first viewing:

  • Lutz was surprised to find that the primary readership of the blog turned out to be the media – “the number one readers of the FastLane blog”
  • he hopes journalists will now pause before writing a “really stupid piece” on GM, in the knowledge that GM has a way of responding and explaining that does not have to be mediated by the mainstream media and they will not want to be embarrassed by being shown up in front of their peers in the FastLane blog
  • he felt that GM were previously treated poorly by the media (always “glass half empty” stories) but he can no longer complain about how new products are treated in the press (“glass half full”)
  • a public-facing corporate blog helps the public to see a corporation less in the old way (a monolith) and more as it is, a collection of diverse individuals, all trying to do the right thing for the shareholders and for the American public
  • in corporate America, official communication had reached a point where it was no longer communication (pre-digested, sanitized, everything positive, no longer taken very seriously because it’s pre-packaged)
  • blogging by various executives where they communicate spontaneously puts a human face on the corporation
  • he thinks if blogging had been around in earlier days, Lee Iaccoca would have been a blogger!
  • internally, blogging is “an incredibly powerful tool for knitting a culture together”
  • in the future, social media will be the preferred means of communication
  • apart from condolences, he almost never writes a letter these days
  • he hopes Ford Motor Company do a lot of internal blogging these days (for their sake)

In my experience, corporate executives are more interested in what other corporate executives have to say about most things, including new technologies, than they are in what consultants and technology salespeople have to say. And rightly so.

Which makes this interview, from my corporate blogging/social media consultant’s viewpoint, pure gold.